In this article
← All articles

Do defensive sectors protect a portfolio in a tech sell-off? Staples, health care and utilities since 2000


Only partly: from 2000 to November 2026, MSCI World's consumer staples, health care and utilities indexes fell less than MSCI World in all five sell-offs we measured, but in euros they still lost between 25.7% and 50.5% in the 2000-2003 and 2007-2009 crashes. The 2000-2003 figures use price indexes, without dividends.

In October 2026, as MSCI World Information Technology fell 5.3% in euros, the three defensive sector indexes rose between 9.7% and 12.7%. That month tells you little about whether a tilt would let you keep investing through a deep crash.

Start with the cash you might need during a crash. The illustrative 70% World and 30% defensive mix still lost 43.7% in 2007-2009. If €50,000 followed that path, it would fall to about €28,150 before costs. Check whether you could meet spending without selling, then ask whether the smaller loss is worth any drag on long-term growth.

Key takeaways

  1. Put the loss in euros. A 43.7% fall in the illustrative mix still removes €437 from every €1,000. Compare the remaining balance with what you might need to withdraw, not just with MSCI World's larger loss.
  2. They are not a separate return engine. In MSCI World's 20 worst months since 2001, an equal mix of the three fell in 19, by 5.3% on average against 8.9%.
  3. A 30% defensive tilt cut the worst loss by 2.0 to 5.3 points per episode. Our illustrative mix lost 43.7% in 2007-2009 instead of 49.0%, and 51.0% in 2000-2003 instead of 55.8%.
  4. The cost in compounded growth depended on the start date. From December 2000 the tilt grew 6.67% a year against 6.69%; from December 2013, 11.80% against 12.41%, before fund costs.
  5. What a household can copy is the check, not the mix. A World ETF already held 18.06% in these three sectors on 30 October 2026, so a tilt adds more of an exposure it already has.

What happened to defensive sectors in the October-November 2026 sell-off?

They rose while technology fell: from 30 September to 18 November 2026, in euros with net dividends, consumer staples gained 16.4%, health care 11.6% and utilities 11.7%, while information technology lost 12.1%. MSCI World itself ended the period 0.7% lower. On 19 November, after this window, the three defensive indexes fell between 1.2% and 2.0% in euros, about as much as MSCI World's 1.8% and information technology's 1.9%.

MSCI World index, net return in EUROctober 202630 Oct to 18 Nov 202630 Sep to 18 Nov 2026
MSCI World+0.97%−1.69%−0.73%
Information Technology−5.34%−7.13%−12.09%
Consumer Staples+12.68%+3.30%+16.40%
Health Care+11.79%−0.13%+11.64%
Utilities+9.74%+1.82%+11.74%

Source: MSCI index levels for indexes 990100, 106803, 106800, 106801 and 106805, daily net return in EUR; episode detail (CSV).

In dollars the same October moves were −6.97% for information technology and +10.74%, +9.86% and +7.85% for the three defensive sectors, matching MSCI's own factsheets of 30 October. The euro figures are higher because the euro fell 1.6% against the dollar in October, from $1.1355 to $1.1172 at ECB reference rates, which raised the euro value of dollar assets.

CNBC reported on 11 November that the IT index "lost 7% in October, and has shed a further 4.6% so far this month". MSCI's dollar price index confirms 4.6% from 30 October to the 9 November close; by 18 November the November fall had reached 8.8%. CNBC also quoted HSBC strategist Alastair Pinder: "The rotation into defensives looks extreme."

The rotation has changed the price of the defensive sectors. On 30 October, MSCI's factsheets put consumer staples on 20.5 times forward earnings and health care on 19.1, against 19.0 for information technology and 17.4 for MSCI World. We do not use these ratios to forecast returns; they show that the move into defensives was not free of valuation risk.

The IT index is also more concentrated than its name suggests: Apple, Nvidia and Microsoft made up 50.3% of it on 30 October. Amazon, Alphabet and Meta sit in other sectors, so the IT index is not the same as the AI trade measured in our November 2026 sell-off analysis.

Did defensive sectors fall less in earlier crashes?

Yes, in every episode we measured, but in the two deep crashes they still lost between a quarter and a half of their value. The illustrative 70/30 tilt cut MSCI World's worst loss by 4.9 points in 2000-2003 and 5.3 points in 2007-2009, and still lost 51.0% and 43.7%.

Largest fall from a high in euros. 2000-2003 tech bust: MSCI World minus 55.8%, 70/30 defensive tilt minus 51.0%, defensive trio minus 42.4%. 2007-2009 financial crisis: minus 49.0%, minus 43.7%, minus 30.7%. 2020 Covid crash: minus 19.8%, minus 17.8%, minus 13.1%. 2022 rate shock: minus 13.5%, minus 10.0%, minus 7.3%. October-November 2026 AI sell-off to 18 November: minus 4.5%, minus 2.4%, minus 1.9%.

Worst loss, MSCI World / 70-30 tilt / defensive trio: 2000-2003 −55.8% / −51.0% / −42.4%; 2007-2009 −49.0% / −43.7% / −30.7%; 2020 −19.8% / −17.8% / −13.1%; 2022 −13.5% / −10.0% / −7.3%; 2026 to 18 November −4.5% / −2.4% / −1.9%. Source: MSCI World index 990100 and the Consumer Staples (106800), Health Care (106801) and Utilities (106805) indexes, in EUR; copio calculations; worst loss by episode (CSV).

Each sector on its own fell less than MSCI World in all five windows. In 2000-2003, on price indexes, consumer staples lost 34.5%, health care 44.6% and utilities 50.5%, against 55.8% for MSCI World and 81.6% for information technology. In 2007-2009, with net dividends, they lost 25.7%, 31.3% and 36.4%, against 49.0%.

Technology was not always the worst place to be. In 2007-2009 the IT index lost 45.7%, less than MSCI World, and in 2020 it lost 15.1% against 19.8%. A sell-off led by technology, as in 2000 and 2022, is where the defensive sectors' gap with IT was widest: 2022 cost IT 26.3% and the defensive mix 7.3%.

Did defensive sectors recover faster?

After the two deep crashes, yes; after the quick falls of 2020 and 2022, the defensive mix took as long as MSCI World or longer. A smaller fall needs a smaller gain: the tilt's 43.7% loss in 2007-2009 needed a 77.6% rise to recover, MSCI World's 49.0% loss a 96.1% rise.

EpisodeMSCI World70/30 tilt (illustration)Defensive trio
2000-2003, price index174 months168 months148 months
2007-200969 months62 months55 months
202010 months10 months14 months
202219 months19 months20 months

Months from each series' own high in the window to the first month-end at or above it, in euros. Source: copio calculations on MSCI month-end levels; episode detail (CSV).

The tilt recovered seven months sooner than MSCI World after 2007-2009 and six months sooner after 2000-2003, a modest gain for losses of that size. Utilities alone took 85 months to regain their May 2007 level, longer than MSCI World. The 2000-2003 figures exclude dividends, which were higher for the defensive sectors, so they overstate every recovery time and the defensive ones most; MSCI's data service gives net-return levels only from December 2000.

Our guide to recovery time and loss maths explains why depth and time below a high are separate risks.

Do defensive sectors diversify a World ETF?

Only within equities: in the 113 months from January 2001 to October 2026 in which MSCI World fell in euros, the equal-weight defensive mix also fell in 84. They softened equity losses on average, but usually fell alongside the rest of the market.

Average return in MSCI World's 20 worst months, January 2001 to October 2026, in euros: MSCI World minus 8.88%; World Information Technology minus 12.11%, fell in 20 of 20; 70/30 tilt minus 7.81%, fell in 20 of 20; World Utilities minus 5.99%, fell in 19; defensive trio minus 5.31%, fell in 19; World Health Care minus 5.11%, fell in 18; World Consumer Staples minus 4.82%, fell in 18.

In MSCI World's 20 worst months: MSCI World −8.88%, IT −12.11%, 70/30 tilt −7.81%, utilities −5.99%, defensive trio −5.31%, health care −5.11%, consumer staples −4.82%; each defensive index fell in 18 or 19 of them. Source: MSCI index levels, month-end net return in EUR; copio calculations; growth and down-month statistics (CSV).

Over all 310 months, the monthly correlation with MSCI World was 0.66 for consumer staples, 0.68 for health care, 0.59 for utilities and 0.73 for the equal-weight mix. In the months when MSCI World fell, the mix's correlation was still 0.70. Each defensive index fell in 68% to 72% of those months.

That is diversification within equities. Losses can be smaller even when holdings fall together. What this mix did not provide was a reliable offset in a crash or evidence of higher compounded growth after costs. Our study of why investments fall at the same time finds the same pattern across equity regions, and the factor ETF study finds it for minimum-volatility indexes.

What did a defensive tilt cost in compounded growth?

Over December 2000 to October 2026, almost nothing: the 70/30 tilt compounded at 6.67% a year against 6.69% for MSCI World, in euros before costs. Measured over ten-year windows with other start dates, the tilt ranged from 1.55 points a year behind MSCI World to 1.08 points ahead.

Annual growth rate in euros, MSCI World, 70/30 tilt and defensive trio. December 2000 to October 2026: 6.69%, 6.67%, 6.29%. December 2000 to September 2026: 6.67%, 6.52%, 5.86%. December 2000 to December 2010: minus 1.28%, minus 0.74%, 0.18%. December 2010 to December 2020: 10.88%, 10.96%, 10.89%. December 2020 to October 2026: 14.08%, 12.79%, 9.40%.

Annual growth, MSCI World / 70-30 tilt / defensive trio: Dec 2000-Oct 2026 6.69% / 6.67% / 6.29%; Dec 2000-Sep 2026 6.67% / 6.52% / 5.86%; 2001-2010 −1.28% / −0.74% / 0.18%; 2011-2020 10.88% / 10.96% / 10.89%; Dec 2020-Oct 2026 14.08% / 12.79% / 9.40%. Source: MSCI index levels, month-end net return in EUR; copio calculations; growth by period (CSV).

The full-period result rests on its end date. Stopping in September 2026, before the defensive sectors' 11.4% October rise in euros, the tilt trailed by 0.15 points a year. From December 2013 to October 2026 it trailed by 0.61 points a year, and €10,000 grew to €41,828 instead of €44,899.

Across the 191 ten-year windows starting between December 2000 and October 2016, the tilt beat MSCI World in 115. The last window in which it did so started in December 2012. On price indexes, which miss dividends but include 2000, the tilt grew faster from December 1999, at the peak of the tech bubble, and slower from December 1998.

Lower volatility did not by itself mean faster growth. The defensive mix alone had an annual volatility of 10.7% against 13.8% for MSCI World, and compounded at 6.29% against 6.69%. The growth advantage in some windows coincided with the sectors holding up better through prolonged losses, as in 2001-2010. That historical result does not establish that smoother returns pay for a tilt after costs.

What can a household check before adding a defensive sector ETF?

These checks use your own statements and fund factsheets; none of them depends on guessing where this sell-off ends.

  1. Look up what your World ETF already holds. On 30 October 2026, health care, consumer staples and utilities were 18.06% of MSCI World and information technology 29.84%; a 30% defensive tilt would lift the three to about 42.6% of the equity mix.
  2. Count defensive sector funds as equities. In 2007-2009 the defensive mix still lost 30.7% and the illustrative tilt 43.7%, so the total you hold in shares is what a crash test should start from.
  3. Name the job the holding should do. The data support a smaller fall in deep crashes, not a faster recovery after quick ones, and not money you can count on for spending within a few years.
  4. Add up the costs the index figures leave out. Compare sector funds' ongoing charges with your World ETF's, and count the trades and any taxes needed to keep a tilt at its target.
  5. Judge over full cycles, not one month. October 2026 alone moved the 26-year growth gap from 0.15 to 0.02 points a year.
  6. Replay past crashes on your own holdings. If you have access to the copio app preview, you can replay past crashes on your holdings and see which holdings are real diversifiers and which fall together.

The independent-bets analysis explains why adding funds that track the same market adds few new return sources. For assets that have moved differently from equities in crashes, see our study of uncorrelated assets for euro investors and the crash study across asset classes.


Sources and method

Checked on 19 November 2026; the 19 November daily moves were added on 20 November 2026 from MSCI's levels retrieved that day.

Index levels: the MSCI index level service behind msci.com/indexes, retrieved on 19 November 2026, for MSCI World (990100), MSCI World Information Technology (106803), Consumer Staples (106800), Health Care (106801) and Utilities (106805). We used month-end net total return levels in EUR from 29 December 2000 to 30 October 2026, month-end price levels in EUR from 31 December 1998, and daily net-return levels in EUR and USD to 18 November 2026. No currency conversion was needed; MSCI calculates the EUR series.

Factsheets dated 30 October 2026: MSCI World (sector weights, top 10 constituents with sectors) and the Information Technology, Consumer Staples, Health Care and Utilities sector factsheets (one-month net returns in USD, forward P/E, top 10 constituents). The sector indexes were launched on 15 September 1999; earlier levels are back-tested and enter only the price-index growth comparison from December 1998.

Exchange rates: ECB euro reference rates, USD per EUR, for the October currency move only. Press: CNBC, 11 November 2026, for the reported IT index moves and the HSBC quote; we checked the index moves against MSCI's levels.

All drawdowns, recovery times, growth rates, correlations, down-month counts and the two portfolios are copio calculations. The defensive trio holds equal thirds of the three defensive indexes; the illustrative tilt holds 70% MSCI World and 10% in each defensive index; both are rebalanced at every month-end (every day in the 2026 window) without costs.

Drawdown is the largest fall from a high to a later low inside each window: December 1999 to December 2003, May 2007 to December 2009, December 2019 to December 2020, December 2021 to December 2022 and 30 September to 18 November 2026. CAGR is (ending level / starting level) raised to the power 12 / months, minus one.

Limits: index returns are before fund costs, trading spreads and taxes; a real tilt would also bear rebalancing costs. The 2000-2003 window uses price indexes because MSCI's net-return series start in December 2000, which understates the defensive sectors' higher dividends. Month-end values miss deeper falls within a month, and the 2026 window uses daily closes, so it is not directly comparable with the others.

Sector membership changes over time, so each sector index describes different companies in different years. Five episodes and one 26-year history are a small sample, and past sector behaviour does not establish how the next sell-off will unfold.

Downloads: worst loss by episode, episode detail with recovery dates, growth by period, growth and down-month statistics and monthly net returns, 2001-2026.

This article is educational, not personalised investment advice.

FAQ

Do defensive sectors protect a portfolio in a stock market crash?

They cushioned falls but did not stop them. In euros, MSCI World's consumer staples, health care and utilities indexes lost 25.7% to 36.4% in 2007-2009, against 49.0% for MSCI World, with net dividends reinvested. On price indexes they lost 34.5% to 50.5% in 2000-2003, against 55.8%. They fell less than MSCI World in all five sell-offs we measured, from 2000 to November 2026.

How did consumer staples, health care and utilities do in the October-November 2026 sell-off?

They rose while technology fell. In euros with net dividends, from 30 September to 18 November 2026, MSCI World Consumer Staples gained 16.4%, Health Care 11.6% and Utilities 11.7%. MSCI World Information Technology lost 12.1% and MSCI World 0.7%. Most of the defensive gain came in October.

Do defensive sector ETFs diversify an MSCI World ETF?

Only within equities. From January 2001 to October 2026, MSCI World fell in 113 months; an equal mix of the three defensive sector indexes fell in 84 of them. In MSCI World's 20 worst months the mix fell in 19, by 5.3% on average against 8.9%, in euros. They soften equity losses rather than adding a return source that rises when equities fall.

What does a defensive tilt cost in long-run growth?

It depended on the start date. A 70% MSCI World and 30% defensive-sector mix, our illustration, compounded at 6.67% a year from December 2000 to October 2026 against 6.69% for MSCI World, in euros before costs. From December 2013 it compounded at 11.80% against 12.41%, so €10,000 became €41,828 instead of €44,899.

Does an MSCI World ETF already hold defensive sectors?

Yes. On 30 October 2026, MSCI's factsheet put health care at 10.19% of MSCI World, consumer staples at 5.37% and utilities at 2.5%, together 18.06%. Information technology was 29.84%. Adding a sector ETF raises a weight the World fund already holds.

Optional cookies help us measure visits and advertising. Choose each purpose, or decline both. You can change your choice using Cookie settings in the footer. Cookie policy.