In this article
← All articles

Do infrastructure ETFs diversify an MSCI World ETF? Correlations, crashes and growth since 2004


Adding listed infrastructure to MSCI World cushioned some falls but did not raise compounded growth under our fee assumptions. From January 2004 to October 2026, an illustrative 80/20 mix grew at 9.35% a year in euros, versus 9.36% for MSCI World alone. Its worst month-end fall was 47.3%, versus 49.2%. The mix led in MSCI's back-test years and trailed from January 2015.

The monthly correlation with MSCI World was 0.75, close to the result in our emerging markets study. Infrastructure moved more closely with MSCI World in falling months than in rising ones, and fell in 23 of MSCI World's 24 worst months. For a portfolio that already holds World equities, the useful distinction is between changing the sector weights and adding a source of return that holds up in a joint sell-off.

Key takeaways

  1. No growth gain over nearly 23 years. With illustrative fees, the 80/20 mix grew at 9.35% a year from January 2004 to October 2026, against 9.36% for World alone. From January 2015 it grew at 10.81% against 11.61%.
  2. The worst fall shrank by about two points. MSCI World's deepest month-end fall after charges was 49.2%; with 20% infrastructure it was 47.3%, and infrastructure alone lost 40.0%.
  3. The two indexes usually lost money together in the worst months. In MSCI World's 24 worst months, infrastructure fell in 23, losing 5.1% on average against 7.1%. Its correlation was 0.75 in MSCI World's falling months and 0.52 in rising ones.
  4. The growth lead came in the back-test. MSCI launched the core infrastructure index on 16 January 2015. Its correlation with MSCI World was 0.84 in the 2004-2014 back-test and 0.71 from January 2015.
  5. The scenario changes the sector mix. On 30 October 2026, utilities were 2.5% of MSCI World and 44.73% of the core infrastructure index. In the 80/20 scenario, utilities rise to about 11% of the equity mix and technology falls from 29.84% to 23.9%.

How closely did infrastructure move with MSCI World?

About as closely as emerging markets: a correlation of 0.75 over 274 months, also 0.75 in MSCI World's falling months and only 0.52 in its rising ones. A linear fit to MSCI World accounts for 57% of the variation in monthly core infrastructure returns in this sample. Our S&P 500 study and factor ETF study use the same method to look at overlap with other equity indexes.

Monthly net returns in EUR, January 2004 to October 2026MSCI World Core InfrastructureMSCI World Utilities
Correlation with MSCI World0.750.56
In months MSCI World fell / rose0.75 / 0.520.57 / 0.27
Beta (move for each 1% move in MSCI World)0.690.53
Volatility a year (MSCI World 12.8%)11.8%12.1%
Months MSCI World fell / months the index also fell95 / 6795 / 62
MSCI World's 24 worst months: also fell / average return (World −7.14%)23 / −5.05%21 / −3.91%

Source: Copio calculation on MSCI Net Total Return EUR indexes; correlation summary (CSV), monthly levels and returns (CSV).

A higher correlation in falling months is the wrong way round for a diversifier: the link tightened when it mattered. The beta of 0.69 is the fitted slope across all months: a one-point change in MSCI World's monthly return was associated with a 0.69-point change in infrastructure's return, not a limit on losses. Its volatility, 11.8% a year against 12.8%, was barely lower.

The link has loosened recently. The rolling 36-month correlation peaked at 0.93 in March 2010 and reached its lowest, 0.34, in October 2026, the latest month (rolling correlation (CSV)). Three years of data are a short window, and the earlier record shows the link can tighten again.

Is an infrastructure ETF just a utilities fund?

In behaviour, largely: the core infrastructure index's monthly returns had a correlation of 0.88 with MSCI World Utilities from 2004 to October 2026. On 30 October 2026, utilities made up 44.73% of the index, against 2.5% of MSCI World.

The index groups are weighted by rule at rebalancing, rather than by market value alone. MSCI's methodology (May 2020, section 2.2) keeps utilities and pipelines at 60% of the index and transport and telecom infrastructure at 40%, caps each sub-industry at 15% and each company at 5%. On 30 October 2026 the two groups stood at 59.43% and 40.57%.

The rest is rail (16.01%), oil and gas pipelines (14.7%), telecom towers (12.99%), airports (5.95%) and toll roads (5.62%), according to MSCI's factsheet. Utilities alone had a lower correlation with MSCI World, 0.56, and fell less in its worst months. Our defensive sectors study covers utilities next to consumer staples and health care, so we do not repeat it here.

Weight by GICS sector at 30 October 2026. Utilities: MSCI World 2.5%, MSCI World Core Infrastructure 44.7%, an illustrative 80% World and 20% infrastructure mix 11.0%. Industrials: 10.8%, 27.6%, 14.1%. Energy: 4.6%, 14.7%, 6.6%. Real estate: 1.6%, 13.0%, 3.9%. Information technology: 29.8%, 0%, 23.9%.

Weight at 30 October 2026, MSCI World / Core Infrastructure / 80-20 mix: utilities 2.5% / 44.73% / 10.95%; industrials 10.76% / 27.58% / 14.12%; energy 4.59% / 14.7% / 6.61%; real estate 1.6% / 12.99% / 3.88%; information technology 29.84% / 0% / 23.87%. Source: MSCI World and MSCI World Core Infrastructure Index (USD) factsheets of 30 October 2026, sub-industries grouped by the GICS structure; Copio calculation; sector weights (CSV).

MSCI World already holds these companies, at small weights. The index picks its companies from its parent index, MSCI World, and the factsheet gives each top-ten holding's weight there, from Union Pacific to American Water Works: together, 37.39% of the infrastructure index and 0.72% of MSCI World. The slice changes the weights of companies you already own rather than adding new markets.

The index holds no data-centre REITs, which GICS classifies as a separate sub-industry: its nine sub-industries add up to 100% without them. Owners of data centres are therefore not part of it; electricity companies are.

Did infrastructure fall less when MSCI World fell?

In seven of the eight falls we studied it did better than MSCI World, falling less in five and rising in two; in the Covid crash it fell slightly more.

Cumulative net returns in EUR during selected MSCI World falls. Financial crisis, May 2007 to February 2009, back-test: MSCI World minus 49.0%, MSCI World Core Infrastructure minus 38.4%. 2011, back-test: minus 14.6% and minus 4.2%. 2015: minus 12.2% and minus 10.8%. 2018: minus 12.0% and minus 2.2%. Covid crash 2020: minus 19.8% and minus 20.1%. 2022 rate shock: minus 13.5% and plus 2.6%. 2025 tariff shock: minus 12.5% and minus 0.5%. 12 October to 19 November 2026: minus 5.3% and plus 5.1%.

MSCI World / MSCI World Core Infrastructure, in EUR: May 2007 to Feb 2009 −49.0% / −38.4% (back-test); 2011 −14.6% / −4.2% (back-test); 2015 −12.2% / −10.8%; 2018 −12.0% / −2.2%; 2020 −19.8% / −20.1%; Dec 2021 to Jun 2022 −13.5% / +2.6%; 2025 −12.5% / −0.5%; 12 Oct to 19 Nov 2026 −5.3% / +5.1%. Source: MSCI index data (MSCI World 990100 and MSCI World Core Infrastructure 706146, net, EUR); Copio calculation; episode returns, with MSCI World Infrastructure and Utilities (CSV).

The first seven episodes are the falls of more than 10% on month-end values from our emerging markets study, measured from MSCI World's high to its low in each window, with the same dates for both indexes. The 2026 sell-off uses daily closes. The 2008 and 2011 figures come from MSCI's back-test for periods before the core index existed.

The Covid crash is the warning. In March 2020, infrastructure lost 14.0% against 13.1% for MSCI World, and it ended 2020 down 9.0% while MSCI World gained 6.3% (calendar years (CSV)). The cushion failed in the fastest fall of the period.

The 2022 record is mixed. Over MSCI World's fall from December 2021 to June 2022, infrastructure gained 2.6%. In September 2022 alone it lost 10.0%, against 6.9% for MSCI World.

The month-end figures also understate the depth of 2008. On MSCI's own daily measure in US dollars, the core index's largest fall was 50.54%, from 21 May 2008 to 9 March 2009, against 57.82% for MSCI World, according to the factsheet (page 1).

What happened in the October-November 2026 sell-off?

Infrastructure rose while MSCI World fell: from MSCI World's record close on 12 October 2026 to 19 November, MSCI World lost 5.3% in euros and MSCI World Core Infrastructure gained 5.1%. MSCI World Utilities gained 5.0% and the wider MSCI World Infrastructure Index, which includes telecom operators, 3.0%.

The core index reached its own record close on 13 November, in the middle of the sell-off. On 19 November both fell, MSCI World by 1.8% and infrastructure by 1.5%, which shows the gap can close quickly on a single day. Our November 2026 AI sell-off analysis covers what happened inside MSCI World, and our stocks and bonds study covers bonds and gold over the same weeks.

Did adding infrastructure raise compounded growth after costs?

With the fees in this scenario, the mixes with 10% to 30% in infrastructure finished close to MSCI World alone. Their lead in the back-test before 2015 was offset by a shortfall from January 2015. The weights illustrate the effect of the tilt; they are not recommended allocations.

Annual growth after illustrative charges, in EUR, rebalanced monthly. World only: January 2004 to October 2026 9.4%, 2004 to 2014 back-test 7.0%, January 2015 to October 2026 11.6%. 90/10: 9.4%, 7.4%, 11.2%. 80/20: 9.4%, 7.8%, 10.8%. 70/30: 9.3%, 8.2%, 10.4%. Infrastructure only: 9.0%, 10.9%, 7.2%. Worst fall on month-end values: minus 49.2%, minus 48.2%, minus 47.3%, minus 46.3%, minus 40.0%.

Growth a year after charges, Jan 2004 to Oct 2026 / 2004 to 2014 / Jan 2015 to Oct 2026: MSCI World only 9.36% / 6.98% / 11.61%; 90% World, 10% infrastructure 9.36% / 7.39% / 11.22%; 80/20 9.35% / 7.79% / 10.81%; 70/30 9.33% / 8.20% / 10.39%; infrastructure only 8.98% / 10.91% / 7.21%. Source: MSCI index data; charges from the iShares Core MSCI World factsheet (0.20%) and the iShares Global Infrastructure factsheet (0.65%); Copio calculation; mix results, gross and net (CSV).

The calculation deducts illustrative fees from index returns, not charges from the returns of an MSCI infrastructure fund. The 0.65% input is a real iShares fee for a different, FTSE-tracking fund and is used only to illustrate the effect of costs. Each 10% in infrastructure added about 0.4 points a year in 2004-2014 and cost about 0.4 points a year from 2015. MSCI launched the index on 16 January 2015, so the first month in the later comparison still includes days before launch.

Calendar years tell the same story. Infrastructure beat MSCI World in 7 of the 11 years from 2004 to 2014 and in 3 of the 11 years from 2015 to 2025. In 2023 it gained 0.5% while MSCI World gained 19.6%.

Ten-year windows show how long a shortfall can last. Of the 155 ten-year periods ending between December 2013 and October 2026, the 80/20 mix grew faster than MSCI World alone in 39%, and in none ending after May 2020. Its shortfall reached 1.18 points a year for the ten years to September 2026.

After charges, EUR, Jan 2004 to Oct 2026World only90/1080/2070/30Infra only
Volatility a year12.8%12.4%12.1%11.9%11.8%
Worst fall on month-end values−49.2%−48.2%−47.3%−46.3%−40.0%
Worst 12 months−37.8%−36.8%−35.8%−35.3%−31.5%
Longest time below a previous high69 months69 months69 months69 months57 months
€10,000 at the end of December 2003 became€77,097€77,069€76,911€76,625€71,227

Source: Copio calculation; mix results (CSV).

The historical cushion was small at these weights. The 80/20 scenario took 1.9 points off the worst fall and 2 points off the worst 12 months, and each blended mix and World alone took 69 months, from May 2007 to February 2013, to regain its high. The infrastructure-only scenario fell 40.0% and took 57 months to recover.

The wider MSCI World Infrastructure Index, which includes telecom operators and has been live since January 2008, is a harsher test. From January 2001 to October 2026, after the same charges, it grew at 3.24% a year against 6.48% for MSCI World, lost 55.6% from January 2001 to March 2003, and an 80/20 mix grew at 5.89% with a worst fall of 49.0% against 49.9%. The result depends on which index a fund tracks.

Where does this leave an MSCI World investor?

In this comparison infrastructure changed the sector mix and cushioned some losses, but it did not provide reliable crash protection. It rose in the selected 2022 and 2026 episodes but fell slightly more than MSCI World in the Covid crash. Its stronger correlation in falling months is a reason not to count it as a separate source of protection.

Under the illustrative fees, the mixes ended near MSCI World alone, with the earlier back-test offsetting the later shortfall of about 0.4 points a year for each 10% tilt. That is not an estimate of what a new fund will earn. A different benchmark or charge can give a different result.

To test for a genuinely different driver, compare how other exposures behaved in the same crashes and how their costs affected long-run compounding. Our falling-months study and uncorrelated assets study measure which ones held up, and when they did not. Our Sharpe ratio and CAGR guide explains why a smoother path alone does not prove faster compounding.

Checks you can run on your own portfolio

  1. Write down the fund's job. The sector snapshot shows a lower technology weight; the loss cushion varied by crash, and the mix did not grow faster from January 2015.
  2. Check the index name. MSCI World Infrastructure includes telecom operators that the core index leaves out, and the iShares fund we use for the charge tracks a FTSE index that includes emerging markets; read your fund's factsheet before comparing it with these figures.
  3. Calculate your look-through utilities weight. Multiply each fund's portfolio weight by its own utilities share on the factsheet, then add the exposures.
  4. Stress the slice with March 2020. In that month infrastructure lost 14.0% and MSCI World 13.1%; ask whether you would sell anything if both fell at once.
  5. Compare the charge with the cushion. In the 80/20 scenario, the assumed 0.65% charge lifts the blended charge from 0.20% to 0.29% a year; the mix's worst fall was about two points smaller.
  6. Look at 2015 to 2026 before deciding. Ask whether you would have kept the fund through years in which it compounded at 7.2% a year after charges, against 11.6% for MSCI World.

Sources and method

Checked on 20 November 2026, with month-end index data to 30 October 2026 and daily data to 19 November 2026.

Index data: MSCI end-of-day index levels, net total return in euros, for MSCI World (990100), MSCI World Core Infrastructure (706146), MSCI World Infrastructure (129867) and MSCI World Utilities (106805), month-end from December 2000 (December 2003 for Core Infrastructure) and daily to 19 November 2026, retrieved on 20 November 2026. The MSCI World month-end levels match those behind our S&P 500 and emerging markets studies exactly. Calendar-year USD returns fetched from the same service match the 2012-2025 figures in both infrastructure factsheets, confirming the index codes.

Factsheets dated 30 October 2026: MSCI World Core Infrastructure Index (USD) (page 1: launch on 16 January 2015, back-test before, maximum drawdown; page 2: top ten, sub-industry and country weights), MSCI World Infrastructure Index (USD) (page 1: launch on 22 January 2008) and MSCI World Index (USD) (page 2: sector weights). Sub-industries are grouped into sectors with MSCI's GICS methodology, August 2024 (GICS structure table).

Charges: iShares Core MSCI World UCITS ETF factsheet (IE00B4L5Y983, total expense ratio 0.20%, October 2026) and iShares Global Infrastructure UCITS ETF factsheet (IE00B1FZS467, total expense ratio 0.65%, October 2026). These charges are illustrative inputs, not market averages; the infrastructure fund tracks the FTSE Global Core Infrastructure Index, not the MSCI index being modelled. The returns do not describe either fund's realised performance.

All correlations, growth rates, drawdowns, mixes, sector sums and episode returns are Copio calculations, reproduced by scripts/infrastructure-diversification.py from the MSCI files. Returns are simple monthly returns from month-end levels; growth is compounded wealth; "after charges" deducts one twelfth of each charge from each monthly index return. Mixes are rebalanced monthly without trading costs or taxes.

Limits: MSCI World Core Infrastructure data before 16 January 2015 and MSCI World Infrastructure data before 22 January 2008 are MSCI back-tests. All figures are in euros, so they include currency moves; about 56% of the core index was in US companies on 30 October 2026. Index returns are after MSCI's standard dividend withholding tax but exclude tracking differences, spreads and investor taxes, and the sector mix has changed over the period.

This article is educational, not personalised investment advice.

FAQ

Do infrastructure ETFs diversify an MSCI World ETF?

Partly. From January 2004 to October 2026, in euros, the monthly returns of MSCI World Core Infrastructure and MSCI World had a correlation of 0.75, about the same as emerging markets. Infrastructure fell in 23 of MSCI World's 24 worst months, though by less in 19 of them: 5.1% on average against 7.1% (Copio calculation). It softened losses more than it offset them.

Did adding infrastructure to MSCI World raise long-term growth?

Not over the whole period. With illustrative annual charges of 0.20% for World and 0.65% for infrastructure, an 80/20 mix rebalanced monthly grew at 9.35% a year from January 2004 to October 2026, against 9.36% for World alone. The mix was ahead in MSCI's 2004-2014 back-test and behind by 0.8 points a year from January 2015, the month the index launched.

How did infrastructure do in the 2008, 2020 and 2022 crashes?

Differently each time. From May 2007 to February 2009, MSCI World Core Infrastructure lost 38.4% in euros against 49.0% for MSCI World, on MSCI's back-tested data. In the Covid crash, January to March 2020, it lost 20.1% against 19.8%. From December 2021 to June 2022 it gained 2.6% while MSCI World lost 13.5%.

How did infrastructure do in the October-November 2026 sell-off?

It rose. From MSCI World's record close on 12 October 2026 to 19 November, MSCI World lost 5.3% in euros and MSCI World Core Infrastructure gained 5.1%, on daily net index values. On 19 November itself both fell, by 1.8% and 1.5%.

Does an MSCI World ETF already hold infrastructure companies?

Yes, at small weights. The core infrastructure index selects its companies from its parent index, MSCI World; on 30 October 2026 its ten largest holdings were 37.39% of the infrastructure index and 0.72% of MSCI World, according to MSCI's factsheet. Utilities were 2.5% of MSCI World and 44.73% of the core infrastructure index.

Optional cookies help us measure visits and advertising. Choose each purpose, or decline both. You can change your choice using Cookie settings in the footer. Cookie policy.