In this article
← All articles

Active ETFs in Europe: what the evidence says about beating index funds after costs


Over the ten years to 30 June 2026, 11.9% of Europe-domiciled active equity funds survived and beat their category's index fund comparator after fees, according to Morningstar. For bond funds the figure was 33.5%. These are combined results for eligible open-end funds and ETFs, not the odds of an individual active ETF outperforming.

Morgan Stanley Investment Management announced four active equity UCITS ETFs on 17 November 2026, and on 19 November BNY Investments and Vanguard introduced their first active bond ETFs in Europe. Of the 479 ETF listings Deutsche Börse added to Xetra in 2026 to 19 November, it classed 216 as active. For an investor comparing funds, the useful checks are what exposure changes, what extra costs compound to, and how much those exposures lost when markets fell.

Key takeaways

  1. An ongoing fee gap compounds. In our equal-return scenario, a fund costing one point a year more than an index fund ends 30 years with 24.6% less wealth.
  2. The average active fund fell further in both sampled down years. In 2018 and 2022, the three active equity categories we checked had asset-weighted losses 2.3 to 9.0 points greater than their indexes.
  3. Different holdings need not add an independent return source. A fund can reduce exposure to an index's largest companies and still lose money in the same markets.
  4. The 11.9% result is not an ETF-only rate. Morningstar counts eligible exchange-traded and open-end funds together.
  5. Review costs and overlap as well as returns. Even the cheapest fifth of the active equity funds in Morningstar's fee comparison posted a ten-year success rate of 18.8%.

What did Morgan Stanley, BNY and Vanguard launch this week?

Three large managers brought 11 active ETFs to European exchanges between 17 and 19 November 2026: four equity funds from Morgan Stanley and seven bond funds from BNY and Vanguard. Morgan Stanley's are AI & Tech Diffusion, Future of Energy, Multipolar World and Europe Top Picks, Ireland-domiciled UCITS ETFs that the manager describes as combining fundamental research with rules-based analysis in its 17 November release.

BNY Investments listed five active bond ETFs on 19 November: global aggregate, global corporate, global high yield, euro corporate and US high yield. In France, only the euro corporate bond fund will be available to investors, the London Stock Exchange announcement states. Vanguard's first two active fixed-income ETFs in Europe were its Active EUR Corporate Bond UCITS ETF and Active USD High Yield Corporate Bond UCITS ETF.

Issuer, Xetra listing dateActive ETFsAsset class
Morgan Stanley IM, 17 Nov 2026AI & Tech Diffusion; Future of Energy; Multipolar World; Europe Top PicksEquity
BNY Investments, 19 Nov 2026Global Aggregate Bond; Global Corporate Bond; Global High Yield; Euro Corporate Bond; US High YieldBonds
Vanguard, 19 Nov 2026Active EUR Corporate Bond; Active USD High Yield Corporate BondBonds

Source: Morgan Stanley release via Business Wire, 17 November 2026; London Stock Exchange, BNY listing, 19 November 2026; Vanguard UK, 19 November 2026; Deutsche Börse new ETF listings. None of the three releases we fetched states the funds' ongoing charges, so we do not quote them; each fund's key information document gives the figure.

How often do active funds beat index funds in Europe?

In Morningstar's results to June 2026, more than one active equity fund in four succeeded over one year, about one in eight over ten years, and one in 25 over ten years in global large-cap blend equity. Morningstar's barometer compares each active fund with the asset-weighted return of the actual index funds and ETFs in its category, after their fees. It covers about 32,000 Europe-domiciled funds and counts a fund that closed or merged as a failure.

Share of Europe-domiciled active ETFs and open-end funds that survived and beat their category's after-fee passive comparator, periods to 30 June 2026. Equity funds, 39 categories: 1 year 28.4%, 3 years 20.3%, 5 years 15.2%, 10 years 11.9%. Bond funds, 21 categories: 1 year 46.8%, 3 years 51.1%, 5 years 47.5%, 10 years 33.5%.

Success rate to 30 June 2026, equity then bond funds: 1 year 28.4% and 46.8%, 3 years 20.3% and 51.1%, 5 years 15.2% and 47.5%, 10 years 11.9% and 33.5%. Source: Morningstar European Active/Passive Barometer, midyear 2026, pages 4, 9 and 10; horizon data (CSV).

The categories a euro investor is most likely to hold show wide differences. Global large-cap blend equity, the largest category by number of funds with 1,434 active funds ten years ago, had a ten-year success rate of 4.0%. Euro corporate bonds, where BNY and Vanguard both launched, reached 45.3%.

Morningstar category, to 30 June 2026Success, 1 year / 10 years
Global large-cap blend equity25.5% / 4.0%
US large-cap blend equity33.9% / 6.3%
Europe large-cap blend equity23.8% / 5.6%
Eurozone large-cap equity19.7% / 4.3%
Global emerging-markets equity64.6% / 26.1%
EUR corporate bond50.8% / 45.3%
EUR government bond50.3% / 18.5%
EUR high-yield bond41.5% / 31.5%

Source: Morningstar barometer, category pages 23 to 62; category data (CSV). Emerging markets show that one good year says little: 64.6% of active funds beat over one year, 26.1% over ten.

S&P's SPIVA scorecard uses a different test: it compares funds with an index before implementation costs. Over the ten years to 31 December 2025, 98.44% of euro-denominated active global equity funds underperformed the S&P World, and only 62.19% of the 1,087 funds survived the decade. We could not retrieve S&P's mid-year 2026 European scorecard, so the SPIVA figures here run to end-2025.

Why does the share of winners fall as the horizon lengthens?

Compounding costs and fund closures both matter to the comparison. Only 56.2% of active equity funds survived the decade, against 67.3% of index funds, and the ten-year success rate was lower in more expensive equity fee groups. The horizons start in different years and contain different sets of funds, so the chart does not track one cohort over time.

Sorted by fees within each category, the cheapest fifth of active equity funds succeeded 18.8% of the time over ten years and the most expensive fifth 4.3%. For bond funds the range was 40.7% to 24.6%.

Morningstar links short fund lives to poor performance and discusses weak security selection and compounding fees as possible contributors. Source: barometer pages 4, 9 and 10; fee quintiles (CSV).

Survivorship bias is the reason these scorecards count closed funds. A fund list that shows only today's funds hides the ones that were merged away after poor results, so the survivors look better than the choice an investor faced ten years ago. The comparisons do not isolate the effect of fees from manager selection or other differences between funds.

What does a fee gap compound to over 20 to 30 years?

A cost gap lowers the compound growth rate by about the same amount every year, so the wealth gap widens with time: one point a year leaves 17.2% less after 20 years and 24.6% less after 30 in our scenario. The scenario gives both funds the same 7% gross return and charges the index fund 0.20%. Neither number is a forecast, and disclosed charges can change over a holding period. Spreads, brokerage and taxes are outside the scenario.

Final wealth lost by the costlier fund compared with the index fund, with the same 7% gross return a year and a 0.20% index fund cost, scenario. Gap of 0.25 points a year: 4.6% after 20 years, 6.8% after 30 years. Gap of 0.5 points: 9.0% and 13.1%. Gap of 1 point: 17.2% and 24.6%. Gap of 1.5 points: 24.6% and 34.6%.

Final wealth lost against the index fund after 20 and 30 years: 0.25-point gap 4.6% and 6.8%; 0.5 points 9.0% and 13.1%; 1 point 17.2% and 24.6%; 1.5 points 24.6% and 34.6%. Source: copio calculation, final wealth ratio ((1 + 6.8% − gap) / 1.068)^years; scenarios (CSV). With a one-point gap, EUR 10,000 grows to about EUR 54,300 after 30 years instead of EUR 72,000.

In the fixed-return scenario, matching the cheaper fund's net return requires the higher-cost fund to earn the fee gap in extra gross return each year. With returns that vary, compare compounded net results over the same dates rather than subtracting the fee gap from an average of annual outcomes. Our study of Jack Bogle's Vanguard funds judges two of his balanced funds against MSCI World net of their expenses.

Do active funds lose less when markets fall?

Not on average in Europe: in 2018 and 2022 the asset-weighted average euro active equity fund fell further than its index in every category we checked, while 2020 was the exception. S&P's year-end scorecards give one-year returns for each category. We took the three equity categories most relevant to a euro investor and the three recent years with a sharp fall: two calendar-year losses and the March 2020 crash.

Calendar-year return in euros of euro-denominated active funds, asset-weighted, and their S&P comparison index. Global equity: 2018 fund minus 8.0%, index minus 3.9%; 2020 fund 6.4%, index 6.0%; 2022 fund minus 16.0%, index minus 11.6%. Europe equity: 2018 minus 13.5% and minus 9.9%; 2020 1.4% and minus 2.8%; 2022 minus 17.5% and minus 8.6%. Eurozone equity: 2018 minus 15.9% and minus 12.8%; 2020 0.8% and 0.3%; 2022 minus 15.1% and minus 12.8%.

Average active fund vs index, euro funds, asset-weighted: global equity 2018 −8.0% vs −3.9%, 2020 +6.4% vs +6.0%, 2022 −16.0% vs −11.6%; Europe equity −13.5% vs −9.9%, +1.4% vs −2.8%, −17.5% vs −8.6%; eurozone −15.9% vs −12.8%, +0.8% vs +0.3%, −15.1% vs −12.8%. Source: S&P Dow Jones Indices, SPIVA Europe Year-End Scorecards 2018, 2020 and 2022, asset-weighted performance tables; down-year data (CSV).

The 2020 result is a real counterexample: only 37% of euro Europe equity funds lagged the S&P Europe 350 that year. S&P notes that March 2020 was the Europe Equity group's largest asset-weighted monthly loss in more than a decade. Beating the index over a calendar year did not spare investors the fall itself.

Calendar-year returns do not show the deepest point of a fall or how long recovery took, so this is weaker evidence than a drawdown study.

A wider measure points the same way: over ten years to end-2025, euro global equity funds earned 0.66 units of return per unit of volatility on an asset-weighted basis, against 0.89 for the S&P World. We found nothing in either scorecard showing that the average active equity fund protected a portfolio in falls.

What does the ETF wrapper change, and what does it not?

An ETF trades during the day, but exchange trading does not establish investment skill or an after-fee advantage. Vanguard and BNY cited intraday trading and daily transparency in their 19 November 2026 launch materials. Those practices can help an investor see and compare holdings, but costs and transparency vary by fund; Morningstar's pooled rate does not test whether the ETF wrapper changes performance.

A new active ETF also has no record of its own. If it follows a strategy the manager runs in an older fund, that fund's results against the index, including in 2018, 2020 and 2022, are the closest evidence available. Our study of Cathie Wood's ARK Innovation ETF shows how far an actively managed ETF can depart from a world index, in both directions.

Is an active fund real diversification or a costly index fund?

An active fund can reduce concentration in the largest stocks without adding an independent source of return. In its 2025 scorecard, S&P notes that underweighting the largest firms can hurt when they lead. It can also leave equity exposure largely intact, as the losses in the three categories in 2018 and 2022 illustrate.

For a household, compare the holdings on a look-through basis: a fund with high overlap may charge more for exposure you already own, while a different set of holdings can still fall for the same reasons. Our independent-bets analysis shows how to test that distinction.

What should you check before choosing an active ETF over an index ETF?

These checks use the fund's documents, the scorecards above and your own holdings; none of them identifies a future winner.

  1. Write down the cost gap. Subtract your index ETF's ongoing costs from the active ETF's, both from the key information documents; that difference is the yearly hurdle.
  2. Look up the category's historical results. Find the fund's Morningstar category in the barometer; its past success rate is a reference, not a forecast for the fund.
  3. Find the strategy's record, not the wrapper's. For a new ETF, look for an older fund with the same strategy and compare it with the index in falling years, not only over the last twelve months.
  4. Compare holdings with your core fund. High overlap means paying an active fee for index exposure; low overlap means a separate bet that should be judged on its own.
  5. Size the downside of being wrong. Use the cost-gap chart: if the manager only matches the index before fees, the gap is your loss, compounded over your horizon.
  6. Check availability where you invest. BNY's announcement states that only its euro corporate bond ETF will be available to investors in France.

Our memory-chip ETF study shows the same checks applied to themed index funds launched near a peak, and our loss maths guide explains why a deeper fall needs a disproportionately larger recovery.


Sources and method

Checked on 20 November 2026. Morningstar, European Active/Passive Barometer, midyear 2026, data to 30 June 2026: key takeaways pages 3 to 5, Exhibits 4, 5, 7 and 8 on pages 9 and 10, category success rates pages 11 to 13, category pages 23 to 62 and methodology pages 81 and 82.

S&P Dow Jones Indices, SPIVA Europe Scorecards, Year-End 2025 (pages 4 and 8, Reports 1a, 2, 3b and 4), and Year-End 2018 (Reports 1 and 4), 2020 (highlights, Reports 1a and 3b) and 2022 (Reports 1a and 3b), linked above. S&P's site refused our requests, so we used Internet Archive copies of these official PDFs and recorded their hashes; we could not obtain the Mid-Year 2026 edition.

Launches: Morgan Stanley Investment Management release, Business Wire, 17 November 2026; BNY Investments announcement on the London Stock Exchange news page, 19 November 2026; Vanguard UK, "Bringing our active expertise to fixed income ETFs", 19 November 2026; Deutsche Börse, New ETFs & ETPs page, retrieved 20 November 2026. Xetra counts are listings, including separate share classes, between 5 January and 19 November 2026, using Deutsche Börse's asset-class labels.

Our calculations are the Xetra counts and the cost-gap scenarios. The category table uses success rates directly, not compounded paths from Morningstar's unlabelled multi-year return figures. Morningstar counts funds that survive and beat an after-fee passive fund composite; SPIVA reports underperformance against an index without implementation costs. The two rates use different benchmarks and fund universes and are not interchangeable. SPIVA's 2018 to 2022 global benchmark was the S&P Global 1200, later the S&P World.

All returns exclude investor trading costs and taxes. The scenarios assume equal gross returns, which is the point of the comparison, not a prediction. Every figure is in the CSV files linked above and in the research ledger.

This article is educational, not personalised investment advice.

FAQ

Do active ETFs beat index funds?

Morningstar's midyear 2026 barometer found that 11.9% of active equity funds survived and beat their category's asset-weighted index fund comparator over the ten years to 30 June 2026, after fees. For bond funds the figure was 33.5%. Both figures pool active ETFs and open-end funds; neither is an ETF-only result.

Do active funds lose less in a market crash?

Not on average in the S&P scorecards we checked. In 2018 and 2022, when their comparison indexes fell, the asset-weighted average euro-denominated global, Europe and eurozone equity fund fell further than its index, by 2.3 to 9.0 points. The average fund beat its index in all three categories over 2020 as a whole, which does not show how it fared at the March trough.

What is the difference between an active ETF and an index ETF?

An index ETF aims to track an index, including through sampling or swaps. An active ETF trades on an exchange too, but its manager chooses exposures to meet a stated objective rather than to replicate an index. Some issuers offer daily holdings disclosure; check the fund's actual costs and strategy rather than assuming either from the wrapper.

Are active bond funds a better bet than active equity funds?

Their odds have been better. Over ten years to June 2026, 45.3% of active euro corporate bond funds survived and beat their index-fund peers, against 4.0% in global large-cap equity, according to Morningstar. Euro government bond funds were weaker, at 18.5%.

What does a 1% fee difference cost over 30 years?

In our scenario with the same 7% gross return a year and a 0.20% index fund cost, a fund costing one point more a year ends 30 years with 24.6% less wealth. EUR 10,000 grows to about EUR 54,300 instead of EUR 72,000. This is a scenario, not a forecast: it holds both gross returns and charges constant.

Optional cookies help us measure visits and advertising. Choose each purpose, or decline both. You can change your choice using Cookie settings in the footer. Cookie policy.